MISHKAT

MISHKAT

Reciprocal Rights in Dignity Based Interfaith Dialogue Based on the Conduct of Imam Reza (A.S.)

Document Type : technical paper

Author
Alireza Ebrahim
Faculty Member, Department of Religions and Mysticism, Tehran North Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran
10.22034/mishkat.2026.550668.2666
Abstract
Historical interfaith dialogues, often marred by violations of reciprocal rights and human dignity by Muslim theologians, led to a prohibition of religious discourse by scholars of other faiths. This study employs a descriptive–analytical methodology to demonstrate that: Imam Reza (A.S.) transcended these detrimental practices. His approach exemplified a framework of reciprocal rights that upheld human dignity. Key manifestations of this dignified engagement in his conduct include: facilitating high-level dialogue, mandating responses from all societal strata to religious opponents, accepting interlocutors’ preliminary conditions, extending invitations for dialogue, eschewing polemics and bias, guaranteeing a secure environment for debate under his patronage, affording precedence to non-Muslim scholars in disputations, employing the vernacular of the interlocutor, grounding arguments in irrefutable evidence, demonstrating respect for social standing while abstaining from invective, extending hospitality and gifts to participants, acknowledging the validity of widespread transmission and consensus within other religious communities, affirming reason as a universal instrument for comprehension, identifying commonalities between Islam and other religions, avoiding the invocation of historical grievances and contentious matters, refraining from personal inquiries, refraining from highlighting an opponent’s deficiencies, restricting arguments to points acknowledged by the interlocutor’s tradition, validating testimony from non-Muslim witnesses, defending the tenets of non-Islamic religions against critiques, and refraining from compelling defeated parties to convert to Islam.
Keywords
Imam Reza (A.S.)
human dignity
human rights
Islamic debates
conduct of Imam Reza (A.S.)
Subjects
1.        Baagil, H. M., 1984, Muslim-Christian Dialogue, WAMY studies on Islam.
2.        Benjamin, D. D., 2005, The Patriarchs of the church of the East, Trans. Youel: A. Baaba, United State of America,
3.        Ben Sasson, , H. H., 2007, “Disputations and Polemics”, Encyclopedia Judaica, ed. Fred Skolni, Keter Pub., Jerusalem.
4.        Bertaina, D., 2007, “The development of Testimony collections in Early Christian Apologetics with Islam’, The Bible in Arab Christianity, ed. D. Thomas, Brill, Boston.
5.        “Omar, Covenant of”, 2007, Encyclopedia Judaica, v. 15, ed. Fred Skolnik, Keter Pub., Jerusalem.
6.         Duri, A. A., “Dayr AL-Djathalik”, EI2. v. 2, Brill, Leiden.
7.        Ben Sasson, H. H., 2007, “Disputations and Polemics”, Encyclopedia Judaica, ed. Fred Skolnik, Keter Pub., Jerusalem.
8.        Ben Sasson, H. H., 1976, “The Middle ages”, A History of the Jewish People, Harvard University Press.
9.        Garsiel, B., 2011, "The Qur'an Deception of Abraham in the Light of Hebrew Bible and Midrash", The Convergence of Judaism and Islam: Religious, Scientific, and Cultural Dimensions, University Press of Florida.
10.      Griffith, H, 2011, “Disputes with Muslims in Syriac Christian Texts from Patriarch John (d. 648)to Bar Hebraous (d. 1286)”, Doctrine and Debates in the East Christian World, Rutledge, London.
11.      Gorgias Encyclopedic Dictionary of the Syriac Heritage: Electronic Edition, “List of Patriarchs.”
12.      Mingan, A., 1928, The apology of Timothy the patriarch before the Caliph Mahdi, Wood Brooke Studies, Cambridge.
13.      Neusner, J., 1968, History of the Jews in Babylonia, Brill Pub. Leiden.
14.      Platt, A, & Gibson, N., 2018, “Inquiring of Beelzebub; Timothy and AL-Jahiz on Christian in Abbasid Legal system”, in Heirs of the Apostles, ed. D. Bertaina, Brill, leiden.
15.      Samir. K. S., 2001, “The Prophet Muhammad as seen by Timothy I and Other Arab Christian Authors”, Syrian Christians under Islam, ed. D. Thomas, Brill, Leiden.
16.      Sherbok, D., 2003, Judaism, History, Belief and Practice, Rutledge, London.
17.      Swanson, M. N., 2003, “The Christian Al-Ma’mun Tradition”, Christians at the Heart of Islamic Rule, ed. D. Thomas, Brill, Leiden.
18.      Thomas of Margᾱ, 1893, The Book of Governers, ed. E.A. Willis Budbe, v.2, keganpaul, Trench, Trubner & co., London.
19.      Mar Aprem, 1976, the Nestorian Fathers, Trichur, Kerala.
20.      Vine, A. R., 1937, the Nestorian Churches, Independent Press, London.